.

And by a prudent flight and cunning save A life which valour could not, from the grave. A better buckler I can soon regain, But who can get another life again? Archilochus

Saturday, January 13, 2018

On the On-Going Media Orchestrated Criminalization of the American (& European) Dream

from the NY Times
LONDON — The Czech president has called Muslim immigrants criminals. The head of Poland’s governing party has said refugees are riddled with disease. The leader of Hungary has described migrants as a poison “concentrating” migrants in asylum centers — with all its obvious and odious echoes of World War II.

So when President Trump said he did not want immigrants from “shithole” countries, there was ringing silence across broad parts of the European Union, especially in the east, and certainly no chorus of condemnation.

In fact, some analysts saw the remarks as fitting a pattern of crude, dehumanizing and racist language to describe migrants and asylum seekers that has steadily edged its way into the mainstream. Coming from the White House, such words may be taken by some as a broader signal that racism is now an acceptable part of political discourse.

“What we see now is a conscious policy to reintroduce language that was previously not acceptable in debate,” said Gerald Knaus, the director of the European Stability Initiative, a Berlin-based research organization that has played a leading role in forming recent European migration policy.

To be sure, Mr. Trump’s choice of words drew condemnation from around the world. Botswana and Haiti asked for meetings with American diplomats to clarify what Mr. Trump said and what he believes. The president of Senegal, Macky Sall, was one of many who saw racism in the remarks. “Africa and black people deserve the respect and consideration of all,” he wrote on Twitter.

Even the Vatican newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano, weighed in, declaring Mr. Trump’s comments “particularly harsh and offensive.”

But the political reality is that migration has become a salient issue — and not only for right-wing, populist and nativist politicians. Across many affluent societies, people are anxious about technological change, rising inequality and stagnant wages, and they have focused their ire at the global flows of capital and, especially, labor. There are also concerns about demographic change, as the world becomes less white and as western societies age.

Moreover, the chaos and violence that have driven people from the Middle East, Southwest Asia and sub-Saharan Africa to seek to live elsewhere, even as far away as Australia and Canada, have also raised fears about refugees who do not appreciate the values of the countries hosting them — or even worse, fears of terrorists taking advantage of humanitarian policies to infiltrate societies and then carry out attacks.

Hours before the news of Mr. Trump’s comments broke on Thursday, the United Nations secretary general, António Guterres, spoke about the need for more “safe, orderly and regular” migration.

He implored nations to “use facts, not prejudice” to address the challenges of migration.

“Globally, migration remains poorly managed,” he acknowledged. “The impact can be seen in the humanitarian crises affecting people on the move, and in the human rights violations suffered by those living in slavery or enduring degrading working conditions. It can be seen, too, in the political impact of public perception that wrongly sees migration as out of control. The consequences include increased mistrust and policies aimed more at stopping than facilitating human movement.”

Mr. Knaus, of the European Stability Initiative, was one of several commentators who expressed fear that Mr. Trump would only embolden xenophobic rhetoric.

“This will have consequences because it’s widely followed,” he said. “In every Austrian and German village, they follow what the U.S. president is doing.”

In Western Europe, heads of government have sometimes described migrants in terms of floods and hordes — but the most abusive language has usually been restricted to far-right opposition politicians like Marine Le Pen in France and Geert Wilders in Holland.

“What is dangerous is if this kind of language migrates from the far-right to the mainstream,” Mr. Knaus added.

But some in migration policy circles fear this transition has already begun.

Several European heads of government were proudly xenophobic in their responses to a refugee crisis in 2015, when more than one million asylum seekers arrived by boat on European shores, prompting a surge in support for far-right parties and nativist rhetoric — particularly in Central and Eastern Europe.

Prominent among them was Viktor Orban, the prime minister of Hungary, who criticized non-Christian migrants and then built a wall to stop migrants from entering Hungary.

European leaders initially distanced themselves from him — in both word and action. But by March 2016, several had come around to his policy suggestions, if not the tone in which he had made them.

While still moderate in tone, some leaders are pursuing policies that are Trumpian in spirit, said Catherine Woollard, secretary general of the European Council on Refugees and Exiles, an alliance of nearly 100 refugee rights groups.

“There’s a denial among many European leaders that they’re anything like Trump — while they promote measures that will have the same impact” as Mr. Trump’s restrictions, she said.

Italy’s relationship with Libyan militias, in which the country provides inducements for Libyans not to send migrants to Europe by boat, is among the policies that has concerned advocates for refugees.

Though the policy has been justified in humanitarian terms, because it has reduced the number of people put at risk in the Mediterranean, it has also trapped thousands of migrants in slavery-like conditions on Libyan soil.

In Brussels, European Union leaders are debating whether and how to change the bloc’s common asylum policy. Central and Eastern European countries are among those that support changes Ms. Woollard believes will curb refugee rights in Europe. But so, too, is Germany, widely seen as one of the countries most sympathetic to refugees.

Then there is a contentious deal between the European Union and Turkey that is aimed at closing the main migration routes into Eastern Europe. European Union leadership has justified this as a humanitarian gesture, since it has curbed the number of migrant shipwrecks.

But Ms. Woollard feels this justification has “sugarcoated” the actions of Western European leaders, as it has also confined thousands of asylum seekers in impoverished conditions in Greece and Turkey.

Restrictive migration policy is “not solely confined to the black sheep in the East,” Ms. Woollard said.

Mr. Knaus, who first dreamed up the parameters of the controversial E.U.-Turkey agreement, said it was wrong to conflate the racist rhetoric of Mr. Trump and Mr. Orban with efforts by less reactionary leaders to exert control over migration.

“There is a danger that in opposing this kind of rhetoric one basically strengthens it because we say that anyone who is in favor of controlling borders is in favor of Trump,” Mr. Knaus said. “That is very dangerous because it concedes to racist politicians that being in favor of control is the same as being racist. And it’s not.”
Nationalism isn't "racism". Conflating the two are but pure "diversionary polemics" intended to distract attention from real issues and force an unquestioned universal acceptance of current state of liberal economic globalism.

22 comments:

(((Thought Criminal))) said...

I don't really try to vivisect Trump's statements because I fully reject the absurd premise that he's not mentally retarded. There's only so much exploration of Trump you can do until your cruelly and gratuitously making fun of a retard. Gotta cut some slack to the severely handicapped.

That all said, America IS superior to every other nation. This isn't just moral preening. With FDR, America elected a gimp AND wheeled him around for 12 years. But now, America has a full fledged certifiable retard in the Oval Office. How many other nations will ever be that bold?

Les Carpenter said...

Hopefully none.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

If the Democrats can put a Commie like Obama in the White House for two terms, the Republic can withstand anything.

Les Carpenter said...

Except Obama is not a communist. That's simply a false narrative. But it plays well with the birthers and conservatives.

Beantown AntiFacist said...

Tell that to his childhood "mentor", Frank Marshall Davis... a certified card- carrying Communist

Beantown AntiFacist said...

...or his red diaper mommy.

Beantown AntiFacist said...

...who met Obama Sr. in her "Russian" class.

Les Carpenter said...

You mean like Melanie's daddy? Oh my.

(((Thought Criminal))) said...

If the Democrats can put a Commie like Obama in the White House for two terms, the Republic can withstand anything.

I'm inclined to agree. America's economy is on the rebound because the government isn't doing anything. It's almost as good as not having a government at all.

But, if we must have a government, why not have one where it's head is mentally retarded and can be guided to desirable behaviors just by faking a telegram full of instructions from the Russian FSB?

We're going to miss having a retarded President in 2019 after he's tweeting from prison.

(((Thought Criminal))) said...

Keep in mind two things:

1.) Leftists are incapable of rational thought.

2.) Trump is a leftist.

Les Carpenter said...

Point 3... Trump is a Genius. He has duped people into believing he is something he is not.

-FJ the Dangerous and Extreme MAGA Jew said...

Melania and her parents were born in a Communist country and couldn't avoid communism. She learned what a sh*thole communism is. Viktor Knavs became a car salesman and his daughter a capitalist millionaire entrepeneur. Obama's mom was born in freedom and yearned for communist 'utopias'. She dated third world losers and died, leaving Barrack to be raised by her Russian apologist and commie loving parents. Big difference.

Les Carpenter said...

So goes the narrative. Without context or history. Projecting values w/out understanding circumstances.

Your values are fine. Your completely biases judgement is not. IMNHO.

Joe Conservative said...

As opposed to YOUR narrative??? Your judgement ISN'T "biased"??? lol!

I just gave you the "circumstances". But please, feel free to "Russia-Russia-Russia" to your heart's content.

(((Thought Criminal))) said...

Crack pipes aside, you need to get back to reality, FJ. Donald Trump is retarded. He's also sworn to obey any command given to him by the Russian government.

The two aren't mutually exclusive, but at least Trump's retardation can and has been exploited by members of the intelligence community who can forge and fake orders from Putin and get them to Trump via his "secret" (lolwtfpwned) communication channels Donnie Jr set up.

(((Thought Criminal))) said...

Level 2

Joe Conservative said...

I'm convinced, beamish! How quickly can we get President Pence into the Oval Office?

Joe Conservative said...

?:)

(((Thought Criminal))) said...

Well, easy. The NSA just has to pass along "orders from Putin" to drink Draino.

(((Thought Criminal))) said...

Just wait for Trump to start tweeting that Draino tastes awesome and you know the deed is done.

Beantown AntiFacist said...

Well, at least it won't be another dishwashing soap video...

Beantown AntiFacist said...

...or Tide pod chaallenge